In a case that has sent shockwaves through a quiet college community, New York State Police are treating the death of 21-year-old Sohail A. Nabi as far more than a routine kayaking mishap. The promising Colgate University senior, just days away from graduation, was found dead in the Schroon River in Warrensburg after his vessel overturned during what should have been a relaxing evening paddle with friends.

Authorities confirmed that Nabi, originally from Yonkers, was kayaking with a small group on Sunday evening, May 10, when he suddenly vanished from sight. His companions later discovered the overturned kayak and immediately raised the alarm. Despite an intensive search, Nabi’s body was only recovered approximately 22 hours later, about 100 feet from the capsized vessel in roughly 12 feet of water.

What has elevated this tragedy from a heartbreaking accident to a potential criminal investigation is a startling revelation from investigators: the young man’s kayak showed clear signs of tampering prior to being used. Sources close to the probe indicate that critical components may have been deliberately compromised, raising disturbing questions about whether someone intentionally endangered Nabi’s life. “This is not simply a case of capsizing due to strong currents or operator error,” one law enforcement official reportedly stated, underscoring the suspicious nature of the evidence.

Nabi was a standout student at Colgate University, set to graduate with the Class of 2026. Friends and classmates describe him as ambitious, kind-hearted, and full of life — someone who balanced academic excellence with a love for outdoor adventures. His sudden loss has left the Hamilton campus in mourning, with university officials issuing statements expressing profound grief and offering counseling support to students.

The Schroon River, known for its scenic beauty but also unpredictable conditions, has seen previous incidents, yet few involving such young, experienced recreational paddlers. Early speculation pointed to cold water shock, fatigue, or swift currents. However, the discovery of pre-use damage to the kayak has shifted the focus toward foul play. Police have not yet named any persons of interest, but they are conducting a thorough forensic examination of the vessel and interviewing everyone in the paddling group.

As the investigation continues, questions swirl: Who had access to the equipment? Were there any prior conflicts or motives? Could this have been a targeted act disguised as an accident? Autopsy results are still pending, which may provide further clarity on the exact cause of death — whether drowning, trauma, or other factors.

This case serves as a grim reminder of how quickly an innocent outing can turn deadly — and how hidden dangers can lurk even in trusted gear. The tight-knit community of Warrensburg and the broader Colgate family are left reeling, demanding answers in the wake of a loss that feels increasingly senseless.

As authorities dig deeper, the public watches closely. What began as a celebration of spring and friendship has become a mystery that could expose darker truths beneath the surface of this river tragedy.