In a move that’s ignited fierce debate across fashion circles and royal watchers alike, British Vogue unveiled its inaugural 50 Best Dressed List in December 2025, catapulting Princess Catherine to the pinnacle as a timeless style influencer while delivering a glaring omission to Meghan Markle. The list, which celebrates Britain’s most impactful fashion figures, positioned the Princess of Wales at the forefront, hailing her as an “eternal influencer” whose elegant, heritage-inspired wardrobe has redefined royal aesthetics in a year of triumphant public returns. Absent from the rankings entirely was the Duchess of Sussex, a silence that spoke volumes louder than any formal rejection, fueling speculation about shifting perceptions in the style world and beyond.

Princess Catherine, 43, made a stunning comeback to public life in 2025 following her health challenges, and her fashion choices reflected resilience and sophistication. From her poised appearance at Trooping the Colour in a crisp white ensemble with nautical nods to her festive red coat at the Christmas carol service, she blended contemporary trends with classic British tailoring. Designers like Alexander McQueen and Jenny Packham featured prominently in her wardrobe, emphasizing sustainable re-wears and subtle nods to royal history. Her inclusion alongside icons such as Kate Moss, Naomi Campbell, and Victoria Beckham underscores her role in elevating British fashion globally, with outfits that command attention without overwhelming the occasion. Analysts point to her deliberate approach—favoring structured silhouettes, muted palettes, and meaningful accessories—as key to her enduring appeal, making her a beacon for modern elegance in turbulent times.

Meghan Markle, 44, who has carved out a distinct path since stepping back from royal duties in 2020, found herself sidelined in this British-centric ranking. Now based in California with Prince Harry, her style has evolved into a blend of Hollywood glamour and entrepreneurial flair, often spotlighting American designers like Oscar de la Renta and Carolina Herrera. In 2025, she made waves at events like the Invictus Games in a sleek monochrome look and a charity gala in an asymmetrical gown, promoting inclusivity and bold statements. However, her absence from Vogue’s list highlights a potential divide: as a non-resident and non-British national by birth, she may not fit the publication’s focus on homegrown talent. This “cold shoulder” has been interpreted by some as a subtle commentary on her post-royal trajectory, where her fashion serves personal branding over institutional ties.

The contrast between the two women extends beyond wardrobes to their public personas. Catherine’s style often reinforces continuity and duty, with re-worn pieces symbolizing thrift and tradition amid economic pressures. Meghan’s, conversely, champions diversity and innovation, frequently incorporating ethical brands and cultural elements. Vogue’s decision to crown Catherine while ignoring Meghan has sparked online fervor, with supporters of each side debating merit versus media bias. Some see it as validation for Catherine’s understated power, while others view Meghan’s exclusion as emblematic of ongoing tensions within royal narratives.

As 2025 closed, this fashion face-off underscored broader themes in celebrity culture: the interplay of influence, nationality, and legacy. British Vogue’s list not only honored sartorial excellence but also drew lines in the sand, reminding us that style is never just about clothes—it’s about the stories they tell. With both women continuing to shape global trends in their unique ways, the fashion world watches eagerly for what 2026 holds.