The BBC’s 2025 Christmas lineup has stirred strong emotions among viewers, but not for the reasons one might expect. While staples like Mrs Brown’s Boys continue to divide audiences with its slapstick humor, a quieter drama has stolen the spotlight: the Christmas special of Beyond Paradise, the popular spin-off from Death in Paradise.

Aired on December 21, 2025, the festive episode centered on the wedding day of DI Humphrey Goodman (Kris Marshall) and Martha Lloyd (Sally Bretton). Set against the picturesque backdrop of Devon, the story wove together holiday crimes, unexpected guests, and a deeply emotional reunion. What truly resonated with audiences, however, was the heartfelt “life-changing reveal” that left many in floods of tears.

Viewers took to social media to express their overwhelming reactions. One fan described it as “a nice harmless Christmas show with a great outcome,” while others admitted to “crying their eyes out” and “ugly tears.” The episode’s blend of light-hearted mystery, romance, and poignant family moments struck a chord, especially during the festive season when emotions run high.

Beyond Paradise has long been praised for its cozy yet clever storytelling, following Humphrey as he solves crimes in the West Country after leaving the Caribbean. The series maintains the charm of its parent show while adding deeper character development and British whimsy. This Christmas special amplified those strengths, delivering joy, laughter, and genuine sentiment without relying on over-the-top comedy.

Contrastingly, the BBC’s decision to slot Mrs Brown’s Boys into prime Christmas Day and New Year’s slots drew criticism. The long-running sitcom, known for its crude humor and family antics, has become a divisive tradition. Some viewers appreciate its unapologetic fun, but many others find it outdated, with complaints ranging from “ruining Christmas” to calls for its removal from the schedule.

Fans of Beyond Paradise argued passionately that the emotional drama deserved a prominent evening slot on Christmas Day itself. “Why didn’t the BBC schedule this instead of EastEnders, Mrs Brown’s Boys, and yet more celebrities?” one viewer questioned. Another added that the show “doesn’t get the credit it deserves,” highlighting its underrated status despite strong performances and loyal followings.

This reaction underscores a broader shift in viewer preferences during the holidays. While broad comedy has its place, there’s growing demand for heartfelt, uplifting stories that evoke real emotion – the kind that brings families together in shared tears and smiles.

As the BBC plans future festive programming, the outpouring for Beyond Paradise suggests a desire for more balanced lineups. In a season meant for warmth and reflection, this “underrated” gem proved that sometimes, the most touching moments come from the quiet corners of the schedule.