cbc.ca

en.wikipedia.org

nationalpost.com

End of the 200-Day Mystery: The Heartbreaking Disappearance of Jack and Lilly Sullivan – A Nation’s Hope Fades into Endless Questions

Eight months. Two hundred and forty-seven days of agonizing uncertainty. That’s how long Canada has held its breath for six-year-old Lilly Sullivan and her four-year-old brother Jack, the bright-eyed siblings who vanished without a trace from their rural Nova Scotia home on May 2, 2025. What began as a frantic search for two children believed to have wandered into the dense woods has evolved into one of the country’s most baffling and emotionally wrenching missing persons cases. As January 2026 dawns, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) continues its intensive investigation, but the absence of answers has left families shattered, communities haunted, and a nation grappling with the unimaginable.

Lilly and Jack lived in a modest trailer on Gairloch Road in Lansdowne Station, Pictou County—a remote, wooded area surrounded by thick brush, steep banks, and nearby waterways. Their mother, Malehya Brooks-Murray, and stepfather, Daniel Martell, shared the home with the children and their one-year-old baby sister. According to the family’s account, the morning of May 2 started quietly. The children had been kept home from Salt Springs Elementary School for the second day due to Lilly having a cough. Around 10 a.m., Brooks-Murray called 911, reporting that Lilly and Jack had slipped out of the house unnoticed while she and Martell dozed with the baby.

cbc.ca

cbc.ca

Martell described hearing the children in the kitchen shortly before, and believing they opened the nearly silent sliding back door to venture outside. He told police he searched immediately, even thinking he heard a scream in the woods—drowned out by a passing helicopter. The property’s isolation amplified the terror: no close neighbors, poor cell service, and vast wilderness that could swallow two small children whole.

The response was swift and massive. By afternoon, RCMP issued a vulnerable persons alert. Ground search and rescue teams, helicopters, drones, K9 units, and hundreds of volunteers descended on the area. Over the following days, searches covered square kilometers of unforgiving terrain. Divers scoured Lansdowne Lake and other bodies of water. Cadaver dogs were later deployed. Yet, nothing—no clothing, no footprints, no signs of struggle. By May 7, just five days in, RCMP scaled back the ground search, with Staff Sgt. Curtis MacKinnon stating the likelihood of survival was low, though they hadn’t given up.

What made this case so chilling was the complete lack of evidence. No confirmed sightings after May 1, when surveillance footage captured the children with family at a Dollarama in nearby New Glasgow—the last independent verification of their existence. Rumors swirled: abduction? Accident in the woods? Something more sinister at home? The RCMP insisted early on there was no evidence of criminality or abduction, treating it under the Missing Persons Act. But as weeks turned to months, the Major Crime Unit took lead, polygraphs were administered, and forensic examinations intensified.

The family’s story drew scrutiny. Court documents unsealed in August 2025 revealed seized items, searched vehicles, and interviews with dozens, including biological father Cody Sullivan (who passed a polygraph) and step-grandmother Janie MacKenzie. Pieces of a pink blanket—identified as Lilly’s—were found, one near the home, another in a trash bag. A child’s boot print sparked hope, but led nowhere. Over 1,000 tips poured in, 8,000+ videos reviewed, yet no breakthroughs.

globalnews.ca

N.S. missing kids: Search by RCMP cadaver dogs fail to turn up …

Paternal grandmother Belynda Gray became the public’s window into the grief. Holding cherished photos of Lilly’s outgoing smile and Jack’s shy demeanor, she searched the woods herself, attended vigils, and pleaded for answers. “They know we love them,” she said through tears, clinging to fading hope. The biological father, estranged for years, expressed devastation. Even as online speculation targeted the mother and stepfather, Gray urged compassion amid the pain.

In October 2025, Nova Scotia offered a $150,000 reward—the province’s maximum—for investigative information. Cadaver dogs covered 40 kilometers without detecting remains. Volunteer searches in November uncovered a child’s T-shirt, blanket, and tricycle, but RCMP deemed them unrelated. As Christmas approached without the children, Gray admitted she’d lost hope they were alive, yet the family decorated trees with their ornaments, refusing to let go.

RCMP updates grew sparse, but in December, Major Crime head Staff Sgt. Rob McCamon expressed confidence the case would resolve, calling it the most voluminous in his career. “All scenarios are considered,” he said, emphasizing deliberate, meticulous work assisted by units across Canada.

The mystery’s grip extends far beyond Pictou County. True crime communities dissect timelines on Reddit and podcasts. Experts call it “unprecedented”—two young children vanishing in broad daylight from home, leaving no trace in a searched area. Comparisons to historical cases evoke chills, but this feels uniquely haunting in its silence.

For the families, every holiday milestone stabs deeper. Jack’s fifth birthday in October passed with a vigil instead of cake. Christmas without their laughter. As 2026 begins, over 200 days since that fateful morning, the question lingers: What happened to Jack and Lilly Sullivan?

The woods remain silent. The investigation endures. And a nation waits, hearts heavy, for the truth that could finally bring closure—or confirm the worst fears. In the faces of these innocent children, we see our own vulnerability, reminding us to hold loved ones closer. Until answers come, Lilly and Jack’s story is a poignant plea: Never stop searching, never stop hoping, never forget.