In the glittering world of NFL superstars, where touchdowns meet high-end dining, Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes and tight end Travis Kelce launched their dream venture: 1587 Prime, a luxurious steakhouse blending Midwest charm with celebrity flair. Named after their iconic jersey numbers – 15 and 87 – the spot opened its doors on September 17, 2025, inside the upscale Loews Kansas City Hotel, coinciding with Mahomes’ 30th birthday bash attended by A-listers like Taylor Swift and country star Kane Brown.

What started as a triumphant fusion of sports legacy and fine cuisine quickly spiraled into controversy. Diners flooded social media with scathing reviews, zeroing in on the menu’s eye-watering prices. A viral Reddit photo of a meager $16 bowl of mashed potatoes – described as “soupy,” “cold,” and unworthy of even a pet’s bowl – ignited the fury. Other gripes included $154 ribeyes, $345 Wagyu tomahawks, and sides like $16 truffle fries that left patrons questioning if the celebrity hype justified the cost. One reviewer tallied a $800 dinner for four, sparking debates: Is this elite dining or just overpriced fame-chasing?

Amid the online storm, Brittany Mahomes, Patrick’s fierce wife and co-owner in spirit, stepped into the fray with unyielding defense. Posting family photos from the restaurant – showing the Mahomes clan beaming around a marble table – she subtly signaled solidarity, brushing off critics as jealous haters blinded by envy. Her words, laced with passion, emphasized the restaurant’s premium quality: hand-selected Wagyu, innovative cocktails like the “Queen B” lychee martini honoring her, and nods to Chiefs lore. “This isn’t just food; it’s an experience where tradition meets innovation,” the vibe echoed, dismissing complaints as sour grapes from those who couldn’t afford the luxury.

But Brittany’s bold stand backfired spectacularly. What she said next – reportedly doubling down on the prices as “worth every penny for true excellence” – stunned followers. It portrayed the venture as unapologetically elite, alienating budget-conscious fans who felt priced out of their heroes’ world. The backlash was swift and savage: thousands reportedly unfollowed her Instagram in protest, with comments exploding in rage. “How tone-deaf can you be?” one fumed. “Celebrities living in bubbles while we struggle!”

Travis Kelce addressed the drama on his podcast, defending the menu while promising tweaks, but the damage lingered. Despite a solid 4.4 Google rating and glowing reviews praising the moody ambiance and personalized touches – like engraved ice cubes and Swift-inspired drinks – the incident highlighted the pitfalls of celebrity businesses. In a city proud of its barbecue roots, 1587 Prime’s fine-dining pivot divided loyalties.

As the Chiefs chase another Super Bowl, this off-field fumble raises questions: Can Mahomes and Kelce win back the hearts (and wallets) of everyday fans? Or has the price outrage permanently tainted their prime empire? One thing’s clear – in the high-stakes game of fame and food, not everyone can stomach the cost.