Police have made a bombshell discovery in the ongoing investigation into the disappearance of two Florida attorneys, Randall “Randy” Spivey, 57, and his nephew Brandon Billmaier, 33. The men vanished during a routine fishing trip in the Gulf of Mexico on December 19, 2025, leaving behind their high-end 42-foot Freeman boat “Unstopp-A-Bull” adrift with engines still running, about 70 miles offshore from Naples, Florida.

Initially, authorities from the U.S. Coast Guard and local agencies treated the case as a possible accident—perhaps one man fell overboard while fighting a fish or handling gear, and the other jumped in to help, only to be swept away by currents or the moving vessel. Two life jackets and a white life ring were missing from the boat, fueling theories of an accidental drowning. The massive search effort covered thousands of square miles but was suspended after several days with no trace of the men. The FBI joined the probe due to the “unusual circumstances,” including the boat found upright, in gear, and fully operational.

Now, in a dramatic development, investigators have identified a suspicious device attached to the underside of the hull. Camouflaged under a layer of white paint to blend seamlessly with the boat’s exterior, the object appears designed to compromise the vessel’s integrity or functionality—potentially a cutting tool, explosive component, or sabotage mechanism capable of causing catastrophic failure at sea. Police sources indicate this find shifts the case firmly toward foul play, ruling out simple mishap.

The boat’s owner, who has cooperated with authorities, has vehemently denied any knowledge or involvement in installing or placing the device. They insist the vessel was in perfect condition prior to the trip and that no modifications had been made. Forensic teams are currently examining the item to determine its exact purpose, origin, and how long it may have been attached without detection. Experts note that such hidden sabotage could explain why the experienced boaters—both avid fishermen familiar with offshore conditions—suddenly found themselves in peril far from shore.

Spivey, a well-known personal injury lawyer based in Fort Myers, and Billmaier, an associate at a Boca Raton law firm and his uncle’s nephew, were reportedly on a family-oriented outing. Family members, including Billmaier’s wife Deborah, have publicly expressed heartbreak and confusion, with early statements suggesting disbelief at how two capable men could vanish without a trace. Social media speculation has ranged from heart-related incidents to more sinister theories involving professional rivalries or targeted attacks, given their legal backgrounds.

This revelation has reignited public interest and raised urgent questions: Who placed the device? Was it meant to sink the boat entirely, or disable it in a way that forced the men overboard? How did it evade pre-trip inspections? Authorities are urging anyone with information to come forward as the investigation intensifies. The discovery transforms what was once a tragic boating accident into a potential criminal conspiracy, leaving loved ones and the community demanding answers in this chilling Gulf mystery.