😱 SIX TEEN BOYS HEAD TO A ST. PATRICK’S DAY PARTY FOR FUN — THEN VANISH INTO THE NIGHT FOREVER: 30 years later, a long-lost surveillance tape shows chilling new figures lurking in the shadows… and a psychic’s haunting vision claims the boys met a horrific fate NO ONE saw coming!

They were just goofing around after drinks and laughs in a basement… headed to the marina for a late-night adventure. But only THREE appear on the grainy footage – where did the other three go? And who are the mysterious strangers caught on camera right after?

Police say tragic accident on icy Lake Ontario… but families scream COVER-UP. Is the dark truth about to surface after three decades of agony?

The details on that tape and the psychic’s bombshell will leave you speechless – click NOW to uncover what really happened to the Lost Boys of Pickering! 👇

Thirty years after six teenage boys vanished in the early hours following a St. Patrick’s Day party, the case known as the Lost Boys of Pickering continues to baffle investigators and haunt the community in this Ontario suburb east of Toronto.

On the night of March 16, 1995, Jay Boyle, 17; Chad Smith, 18; Robbie Rumboldt, 17; Jamie Lefebvre, 17; Michael Cummins, 17; and Danny Higgins, 16, were among friends enjoying drinks and laughter at a basement house party in Pickering. The group, typical high school teens looking for fun during spring break, left the gathering around 12:50 a.m. on March 17, heading toward the nearby East Shore Marina at Frenchman’s Bay on Lake Ontario.

What happened next has never been fully explained. Surveillance footage from the marina captured three of the boys—identified by families as Cummins, Lefebvre, and Rumboldt—entering the area at approximately 1:48 a.m. The video showed them breaking into the marina, but no footage depicted them stealing boats or leaving on the water. Notably, Boyle, Smith, and Higgins do not appear on the tape, raising questions about whether all six were together at that point.

Residents in the area reported hearing the sound of a motorboat between 2:30 a.m. and 3 a.m. Two vessels were later reported missing from nearby marinas: a 14-foot Boston Whaler replica and a water tricycle. Durham Regional Police concluded that the boys, likely impaired from alcohol, stole the boats for a joyride on the frigid Lake Ontario waters. Without life jackets and in cold March conditions, authorities theorized the group capsized, succumbing to hypothermia or drowning.

Searches of the lake and surrounding areas began after girlfriends of some of the boys reported them missing early that morning. However, a full-scale search on the water was delayed for about 36 hours, a point of contention for families who argue it reduced chances of recovery. Extensive efforts involving police, volunteers, and helicopters turned up no bodies, no wreckage, and minimal evidence.

The only physical items potentially linked to the case emerged years later. A gas can associated with one of the missing boats washed up in Wilson, New York—over 2,400 miles away by water route, though feasible via lake currents. In 1998, a pair of red Levi’s jeans, similar to those worn by Boyle on the night he vanished, was recovered in debris near the Niagara River. DNA testing, however, ruled out a match to Boyle.

Durham police suspended the active search after 36 hours, classifying the incident as a likely tragic misadventure. The case remains open but inactive, with no new leads prompting renewed efforts as of December 2025.

Families of the boys have long disputed the official narrative. Some relatives, including those of Boyle and Higgins, question whether all six even reached the marina together. Reports indicate Higgins argued with Boyle at the party and may have left early. Private investigator Bruce Ricketts, who took interest in the case over a decade ago and authored a book on it before his death in January 2024, highlighted overlooked details in the surveillance footage.

Ricketts noted that, in addition to the three identified boys, the tape showed three other individuals—two females and one male—entering the marina service area shortly after. He sought to identify these people, suggesting they could provide crucial information, but no breakthroughs resulted. Ricketts also criticized the initial police response, claiming reports from girlfriends were not taken seriously enough and that the investigation closed prematurely.

Psychic involvement added another layer to the public’s fascination. In one account, a psychic consulted by a family member described a “vision” sensing the boys had passed shortly after disappearing, with a feeling they were “not here.” While such claims are anecdotal and not part of official records, they fueled alternative theories ranging from foul play to hidden involvement by others at the marina.

The Pickering community has marked the anniversary each St. Patrick’s Day with gatherings at Frenchman’s Bay, releasing balloons and laying flowers in remembrance. Families continue to grapple with the lack of closure, describing the ongoing pain of unanswered questions.

Jay Boyle was remembered as a talented baseball player with a promising fastball, though he faced some legal troubles including assault charges. He had a young daughter at the time. Chad Smith, the oldest, was known for his outgoing nature. Robbie Rumboldt, Jamie Lefebvre, Michael Cummins, and Danny Higgins—the youngest—were typical teens involved in school and local activities.

The disappearance profoundly impacted Pickering, a quiet suburban area at the time. Parents became more vigilant, and the case served as a cautionary tale about teenage risks. Nationally, it drew comparisons to other unsolved Canadian mysteries, appearing in media, podcasts, and online discussions.

Experts on cold-water incidents note that Lake Ontario’s depth and currents make recoveries difficult, especially in spring when bodies may not surface due to low temperatures. Hypothermia can set in rapidly, and without flotation devices, survival odds plummet.

Alternative theories persist online and among skeptics. Some speculate foul play, perhaps an encounter with the unidentified individuals on the tape or a confrontation during the alleged boat theft. Others point to the boys possibly splitting up, with outcomes varying. However, no evidence supports criminal involvement, and police have found nothing to contradict the accidental drowning theory.

As of late 2025, with the 30-year mark passed earlier this year, no bodies have been recovered, and no charges filed. Durham Regional Police maintain the file as a missing persons case presumed fatal. Families have expressed mixed feelings about closure—some hold faint hope, while others seek acceptance.

Recent media coverage, including articles revisiting the surveillance tape and psychic accounts, has renewed public interest but yielded no new tips. The National Center for Missing Persons continues to list the boys, with age-progressed images imagining them in their late 40s today.

The Lost Boys of Pickering endure as one of Canada’s most perplexing group disappearances, a stark reminder of how a night of youthful exuberance can lead to irreversible tragedy. For the families and community, the passage of three decades has not dulled the sense of loss or the desire for definitive answers.