In a devastating turn that has left families shattered and communities in mourning, authorities have confirmed the grim discovery: the bodies of Randall Spivey, 57, and his nephew Brandon Billmaier, 33, have been recovered after washing ashore in a southern harbor along the U.S. Gulf Coast. The news ends months of agonizing uncertainty that began with what should have been a simple, joyful fishing outing.

The two experienced boaters—both respected attorneys from Florida—set off before dawn on December 19, 2025, aboard Spivey’s 42-foot Freeman vessel named “Unstopp-A-Bull.” They headed roughly 100 miles offshore from the Fort Myers area for a day of deep-sea fishing, a pastime they shared regularly as uncle and nephew. Family expected them back by sunset, but as darkness fell and no word came, panic set in. Their loved ones alerted the U.S. Coast Guard around 9 p.m. that night.

By midnight, a Coast Guard helicopter crew located the boat drifting aimlessly about 70 miles west of Fort Myers, engines still running and in gear—an eerie scene that suggested something went terribly wrong in an instant. A rescue swimmer boarded, shut down the vessel, and anchored it for safety before it was towed to Fort Myers Beach for examination. What investigators found only deepened the mystery: two life jackets were missing, phones remained aboard, but the men had vanished without a trace.

A massive search-and-rescue operation ensued, involving Coast Guard air and sea crews, local sheriff’s offices, volunteers, and even military support. Over 6,700 square miles—an area comparable to the state of Connecticut—were scoured relentlessly for days. Family members clung to hope, posting emotional pleas online and believing the men might have donned the missing life jackets after one fell overboard and the other heroically jumped in to help, unaware the boat would speed away unmanned.

Yet, as time passed with no sightings, the Coast Guard made the painful decision to suspend active searching on December 22, transitioning the case to a recovery and investigative phase. The FBI joined to probe possible foul play or unusual circumstances, while loved ones held vigils and shared memories of the men’s vibrant lives—Spivey a prominent injury lawyer in Fort Myers, Billmaier a dedicated family man from the Boca Raton area.

Now, the worst fears have been realized. The bodies, found drifting into the harbor, confirm the unthinkable: no miracle occurred. The Gulf’s currents carried them home in the cruelest way, closing a chapter that began with excitement and ended in unimaginable grief.

Friends and family describe the duo as inseparable, always laughing, always planning the next adventure. Their sudden loss has left wives, children, and extended relatives heartbroken, grappling with unanswered questions about that fateful day. What caused them to end up in the water? A rogue wave? An accident on deck? Or something more?

This tragedy serves as a somber reminder of the sea’s unforgiving power, even for the most prepared. As investigations continue, the focus shifts to honoring their memory and supporting those left behind. Rest in peace, Randall and Brandon—your story touched many, and your absence will be felt forever.