Greg Gutfeld’s What Did I Miss? redefined reality TV in its 2025 finale with a jaw-dropping twist: contestants faced hidden camera pranks after guessing real vs. fake headlines. One contestant, fresh from 90 days in isolation, fell for a staged “alien reporter” prank, thinking it was a real scoop. Greg’s reaction—doubling over in laughter while yelling, “We’ve gone too far!”—became an instant viral hit.

The show’s format, where contestants guess bizarre news stories, was amped up with a prank war. Kat Timpf orchestrated a fake “breaking news” segment, convincing a contestant that a cat was running for president. Tyrus upped the ante by pretending to be a “security guard” chasing a prop chicken across the set. The real bombshell? Greg himself was pranked when panelists swapped his script with a list of dad jokes, leaving him flustered but cracking up.

Clips flooded X, with #GutfeldPrankWar trending as fans shared memes of Greg “reporting” on alien cats. Greg later admitted the prank twist was a risk. “We wanted chaos, and we got it!” he said. The show’s blend of satire and absurdity sparked debates about media trust, with some praising its creativity and others questioning its ethics.

Despite a near-disaster when a prop fell mid-prank, the finale’s energy was electric, cementing Greg’s reputation as a master of comedic chaos. Fans are already clamoring for season two, eager for more unpredictable twists.