On the night Lily and Jack Sullivan vanished, one detail has emerged that investigators say changed everything.

May 1st, 2025.
11:47 PM.

A security camera at a gas station roughly 30 kilometers from the Sullivan family home captured a vehicle matching the pickup truck driven by Daniel Martell. The footage shows a figure exiting the truck, pumping gas, and entering the store.

This moment, investigators say, represents the last independently verified point in time that Lily and Jack Sullivan were alive.

And it directly contradicts what Daniel Martell told police.

The Night That Now Defines the Case

For months, the timeline surrounding the children’s disappearance remained unclear. Investigators relied heavily on statements provided by Martell, who told authorities he had been home throughout the night.

That statement is now known to be false.

According to investigators, the gas station footage places Martell far from the Sullivan residence during a critical window — at a time when the children’s fate is believed to have been sealed.

“This is not a minor discrepancy,” one investigator said. “This is a provable lie.”

The Surveillance Footage

The security video, recorded at 11:47 PM, shows a truck with features consistent with Martell’s vehicle pulling into the station. While the footage is grainy, investigators say the vehicle’s size, shape, and identifying details align closely with Martell’s truck.

A man exits the driver’s side, refuels, and briefly enters the store before leaving.

No one else is visible in the vehicle.

Authorities say the stop appears deliberate, not accidental — and they are now focused on what occurred before and after that moment.

Why the Location Matters

The gas station is located approximately 30 kilometers from the Sullivan home — a distance investigators say cannot be explained by routine errands or short drives.

For detectives, the location alone raised immediate concerns.

If Martell was home, as he claimed, there would be no reason for his truck to appear that far away near midnight. The discovery forced investigators to reassess every detail of his account.

“This trip didn’t fit any innocent narrative,” a source familiar with the case said.

The Lie That Changed Everything

When confronted with the footage, investigators say Martell struggled to provide a clear explanation.

He had previously insisted he never left the house that night.

The contradiction undermined his credibility and elevated him from a peripheral figure to the central focus of the investigation.

Authorities stress that lies during missing-person cases are often more revealing than confessions.

“People lie when the truth hurts them,” one investigator noted.

The Last Verified Night

Perhaps the most haunting aspect of the discovery is its timing.

Investigators now believe May 1st, 2025, was the last night Lily and Jack Sullivan were alive in any way that can be independently verified.

After that point, there are no confirmed sightings. No messages. No credible witnesses.

The gas station footage stands as the final timestamp before silence.

Why Investigators Say the Trip Can’t Be Explained

Police say they have explored multiple innocent explanations for the midnight drive — and none align with the evidence.

There were no emergencies reported. No confirmed errands. No corroborating witnesses.

The stop occurred late at night, far from home, and during a window Martell explicitly claimed he was asleep.

That combination, investigators say, is deeply troubling.

From Suspicion to Evidence

Before the footage surfaced, much of the case relied on circumstantial concerns and inconsistencies.

This changed that.

The gas station video provided something investigators lacked: independent verification.

Unlike witness statements, the camera does not forget or reinterpret.

“This is evidence that speaks for itself,” an official said.

What Police Are Now Focusing On

With the midnight trip confirmed, investigators are now reconstructing Martell’s movements minute by minute.

They are analyzing travel time, fuel records, phone data, and possible routes taken before and after the stop.

Authorities believe the answers lie not only in where he went — but why he went there.

A Case That Turned on One Camera

For months, questions outnumbered answers.

One camera changed that balance.

The gas station footage didn’t solve the case — but it exposed a lie that investigators say they can no longer ignore.

And in cases involving missing children, lies often mark the beginning of the truth.

What Comes Next

Police have not announced charges, but they acknowledge the investigation has entered a decisive phase.

The midnight trip has become a cornerstone of the case — a moment Daniel Martell cannot explain away.

For Lily and Jack Sullivan, it may represent the final chance for answers.

And for investigators, it is the evidence that finally broke through the silence.