Prime Video closed the book on the Culpables trilogy with Culpa Nuestra on October 16, 2025, and the internet hasn’t recovered since. Nicole Wallace and Gabriel Guevara bid farewell to Noah and Nick in a finale so raw, so electric, that it instantly became the platform’s most-watched international original finale ever, surpassing even Culpa Tuya’s monster numbers from 2024. Within 72 hours, the film rocketed to number one in 87 countries, racking up 42 million views in its first week alone, proof that whatever magic the duo created on screen remains untouchable.

Yet the louder the on-screen passion roared, the quieter their real-life story became. What started as inseparable press tours, matching Instagram stories, and playful TikToks in 2023 slowly dissolved into separate red carpets, scripted joint interviews, and a silence so loud fans built entire timelines around it. By the time Culpa Nuestra premiered in Madrid, Wallace and Guevara posed meters apart, smiling for cameras but never quite at each other, a stark contrast to the 2023 My Fault junket where they finished each other’s sentences and laughed like no one else existed.

Sources close to production confirm the shift began during Culpa Tuya reshoots in early 2024. A single heated exchange on set reportedly paused filming for hours, requiring directors Domingo González and Laura Mora to step in. From that moment, schedules were adjusted to limit overlap, and joint press obligations were carefully choreographed. The now-infamous sofa interview that went viral days before the Nuestra launch—where both stars read pre-written answers from notecards in Spanish—was reportedly filmed in two separate rooms and stitched together in post-production, a detail eagle-eyed fans spotted immediately thanks to mismatched lighting and zero shared glances.

Wallace, now 23, has repeatedly told Spanish outlets she’s happily single and laser-focused on her career, fresh off signing an exclusive development deal with Amazon MGM Studios. Guevara, 24, has been openly dating actress María de Nati since spring 2024; the couple spent New Year’s Eve 2024 in Ibiza and still flood timelines with cozy couple pics as recently as October 2025. Neither actor has ever confirmed nor denied a past romance, sticking to the same polished line: “We’ve known each other since we were teenagers and share an incredible professional bond.”

Still, the fan detective work never stops. Old clips resurface daily—Wallace calling Guevara “mi persona favorita” in a 2023 live, Guevara hyping her Vogue Spain cover with heart emojis before the great unfollow of November 2023, joint hotel balcony photos from the My Fault Lisbon premiere that vanished overnight. Mercedes Ron herself, author of the original novels, told Variety the duo’s chemistry was “the rare kind that can’t be manufactured,” adding fuel to the eternal debate: was it acting… or acting that got too close to the truth?

Culpa Nuestra’s emotional climax—Nick and Noah finally choosing each other against every odd, every family secret, every toxic pattern—hits differently when you remember the leads barely spoke off camera during the final weeks of filming. Critics praised Wallace’s “devastating vulnerability” and Guevara’s “raw, career-best tenderness,” with The Hollywood Reporter declaring their reunion scene “the kind of moment that makes you forget you’re watching fiction.” Viewers agree: X trends for “Nick and Noah endgame” topped global charts for 48 hours straight, while TikTok edits set to Lana Del Rey and The Weeknd have already crossed 200 million views.

Amazon confirms the trilogy has now surpassed 150 million global views combined, making it the streamer’s biggest non-English franchise ever. An English-language remake, starring emerging talent and produced by the same team, quietly dropped on the platform in February 2025 and cracked the U.S. top 10 for three weeks running. Ron’s fourth Culpables book, a spin-off following Dan and Jenna, is already in early development, though neither Wallace nor Guevara is attached.

As the credits rolled on the saga that defined a generation of Spanish romance, one question lingers louder than any streaming record: what happens when the chemistry is real enough to break the internet, but not quite real enough to last past “cut”? Wallace is already in Prague shooting her next lead role opposite a major British heartthrob. Guevara and De Nati were spotted house-hunting in Madrid’s Salamanca district last month. Life moves forward, but the replays never stop.

Fans keep the flame alive in group chats and Discord servers, rewatching the trilogy on loop, pausing on every lingering stare, every almost-kiss that felt too genuine to be scripted. Because sometimes the most heartbreaking love stories aren’t the ones on screen; they’re the ones we’ll never truly know.