Prime Video’s sizzling Culpables franchise, better known to English-speaking audiences as the My Fault series, has kept millions hooked since the 2023 debut of Culpa Mía. Starring Nicole Wallace as the resilient Noah and Gabriel Guevara as the brooding Nick, the Spanish originals exploded onto the global stage, racking up record viewership and spawning an English-language remake with My Fault: London. But as the trilogy wrapped with Culpa Nuestra in October 2025, fans are buzzing over unconfirmed reports of a potential fourth installment—dubbed by some as Culpa Mia 4—that could extend Noah and Nick’s turbulent romance beyond the books.

The original trilogy, adapted from Mercedes Ron’s Wattpad sensation, followed the step-siblings’ enemies-to-lovers arc through forbidden attraction, family drama, and high-stakes betrayals. Culpa Mía introduced Noah’s relocation to her mother’s new husband’s lavish estate, where sparks flew with Nick amid illegal races and simmering tension. Culpa Tuya upped the ante in 2024, testing their bond with college life, new rivals, and parental interference, culminating in a gut-wrenching split. Then came Culpa Nuestra—released October 16, 2025—as the supposed finale, leaping four years ahead to a wedding reunion where unresolved grudges clashed with lingering passion. Nick, now steering his grandfather’s empire, and Noah, launching her career, grappled with forgiveness against backdrops of Spain and London.

Director Domingo González, who helmed all three Spanish entries, teased Culpa Nuestra as the pinnacle, promising deeper emotional stakes than its predecessors. Early reviews praised the film’s mature handling of themes like betrayal and redemption, with Wallace and Guevara’s chemistry carrying the 112-minute runtime. It debuted to strong numbers, trending in over 170 countries and solidifying the series as Prime Video’s top international original.

Parallel to the originals, Prime Video launched My Fault: London in February 2025—a British remake of the first film starring Asha Banks and Matthew Broome. Shifting the setting from Spain’s sun-soaked coasts to London’s gritty underground, it toned down some toxicities while amplifying emotional intimacy. The remake’s success prompted quick greenlights for Your Fault: London and Our Fault: London, completing a separate English trilogy.

Rumors of a true fourth chapter surfaced in fan forums and social media around early November 2025, fueled by alleged set photos and cryptic posts from crew members. Speculation points to an extension beyond Ron’s books, possibly bridging the Spanish and English universes or exploring post-finale fallout. Leaked trailer clips—circulating on platforms like TikTok and Reddit—show high-octane chases, heated confrontations, and glimpses of Noah and Nick in unfamiliar territories, hinting at international threats or long-buried family secrets resurfacing.

Prime Video has yet to confirm, but insiders note the franchise’s profitability: Culpa Mía held top spots in 190 countries, while the London remake drew praise for modernizing the trope-heavy narrative. González has hinted in interviews that fan demand could inspire more, especially after Culpa Nuestra’s cliffhanger teases left doors ajar.

Critics have mixed takes on the series’ evolution. Early entries drew comparisons to After and Fifty Shades for their steamy, dramatic flair, but later films shifted toward character growth. Culpa Nuestra earned a 5.3 on IMDb, with praise for production values—filmed in opulent Madrid and London locales—and criticism for rushed pacing in subplots involving supporting cast like Marta Hazas and Iván Sánchez.

The English remakes, meanwhile, appeal to broader audiences by softening edges: ages adjusted closer, toxicity dialed back, and focus on mutual support. My Fault: London grossed strong streaming hours, proving the formula’s endurance.

If Culpa Mia 4 materializes, it could reunite Wallace and Guevara, capitalizing on their real-life chemistry (despite reported off-screen tensions during promotions). Plot leaks suggest a “final race” metaphor extended literally—Nick defending his empire from corporate rivals while Noah uncovers truths about her past, pulling them into danger together.

Skeptics argue the story concluded satisfyingly in Culpa Nuestra, where love triumphs over odds. Yet, with Prime Video expanding YA slates—think Maxton Hall and The Summer I Turned Pretty—the appetite for more forbidden romance remains high.

As of November 10, 2025, no official trailer or date exists for a fourth film, but leaked content has sparked petitions and fan theories. Whether it’s fan edits or genuine previews, the buzz underscores the Culpables phenomenon: a Wattpad underdog turned streaming juggernaut.

Ron herself has expressed surprise at the adaptations’ reach, crediting readers for pushing boundaries. If history repeats, expect announcements soon—perhaps tying into the London sequels’ momentum.

For now, rewatches of the trilogy dominate charts, with Culpa Nuestra still in Prime’s top 10 globally. The forbidden fire between Noah and Nick refuses to dim, proving some stories demand encores.