🚨 CONTROVERSIAL HOT TAKE EXPLODING ONLINE: “They’re honoring Alex Pretti like a martyr while completely forgetting a nurse who deserved way more sympathy—Laken Riley!” 😡🔥

You’ve seen the non-stop tributes for Pretti—the VA ICU hero gunned down by feds in Minneapolis, sparking massive protests and viral videos. But now, voices are raging: Why all the outrage for HIM, when Laken Riley—a bright young nursing student brutally mur-dered by an illegal immigrant—got crickets from the same crowds?

Critics are calling it hypocrisy on steroids: Pretti confronted agents armed and protesting ICE raids… Riley was just jogging on campus when her life was stolen. “One gets riots and memorials, the other gets forgotten—whose side are YOU on?”

Read more:

A growing wave of online commentary has ignited controversy surrounding the fatal shooting of 37-year-old ICU nurse Alex Pretti by U.S. Border Patrol agents on January 24, 2026, with critics accusing media and activists of selective outrage by honoring Pretti while overlooking the 2024 murder of nursing student Laken Riley, whom they argue deserved greater sympathy.

The opinion, circulating on social media platforms and conservative outlets, questions why Pretti’s death has prompted widespread protests, vigils, and national media coverage—leading to operational changes in federal immigration enforcement—while Riley’s killing by an undocumented immigrant received comparatively less sustained attention from progressive groups. “They’re glorifying Alex Pretti and forgetting a nurse who deserved way more sympathy—that’s Laken Riley,” reads one viral post, reflecting a sentiment echoed in forums like Reddit and Facebook, where users debate the perceived disparities in public response.

Pretti, a registered nurse at the Minneapolis VA Health Care System, was killed during a confrontation amid protests against a surge in immigration raids in the city. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) stated agents fired in self-defense after Pretti approached armed with a 9mm semiautomatic handgun and resisted disarming during an operation. Bystander videos analyzed by outlets including The New York Times and CBS News show Pretti holding a cellphone with one hand raised before agents tackled him, removed the weapon from his waistband, and discharged up to 10 rounds shortly thereafter. Pretti held a valid concealed carry permit and had no criminal record.

His death has fueled demonstrations across Minneapolis and beyond, with health care unions, veterans’ groups, and community activists demanding accountability. Tributes at the VA hospital included an honor walk typically reserved for deceased veterans, and a resurfaced 2024 video of Pretti delivering a heartfelt salute to a dying Air Force patient amplified his image as a compassionate caregiver. President Donald Trump requested the departure of Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino from the region and signaled de-escalation measures amid backlash.

In contrast, Laken Riley, a 22-year-old nursing student at Augusta University in Georgia, was murdered on February 22, 2024, while jogging on the University of Georgia campus. Jose Antonio Ibarra, a Venezuelan national who entered the U.S. illegally in 2022, was charged with malice murder, felony murder, aggravated battery, aggravated assault, false imprisonment, kidnapping, hindering a 911 call, and concealing the death of another. Prosecutors alleged Ibarra bludgeoned Riley with a rock after abducting her, leading to her death from blunt force trauma.

Riley’s case became a flashpoint in national debates over immigration policy during the 2024 presidential election, with Republicans, including Trump, citing it as evidence of lax border security under the Biden administration. Her family attended the Republican National Convention, where her story was highlighted alongside other victims of crimes committed by undocumented immigrants. Georgia Governor Brian Kemp signed legislation enhancing cooperation between local law enforcement and federal immigration authorities in response. However, progressive critics argued the focus on Riley’s case risked stigmatizing all immigrants and distracted from broader issues like campus safety and violence against women.

The latest opinions comparing the two cases argue that Riley, as an innocent victim attacked without provocation, warrants more empathy than Pretti, whom some portray as actively engaging in a volatile situation. A Reddit thread titled “False equivalences being used to describe these ICE situations” garnered dozens of comments, with users noting key differences: Riley was unarmed and not involved in any confrontation, while Pretti was protesting and carrying a firearm. “I’ve seen people try to compare these situations and they couldn’t be more different,” one commenter wrote.

Social media analyses, such as those from Times Now, highlight “unequal comparisons” between the deaths, pointing out both were in the nursing field—Riley as a student aspiring to the profession, Pretti as a practicing ICU nurse. Posts question why Pretti’s shooting led to immediate protests and calls for federal pullbacks, while Riley’s murder, though politicized, did not spark similar widespread demonstrations against immigration policies from the left. Conservative commentators have accused mainstream media of bias, suggesting Pretti’s case fits narratives critical of Trump-era enforcement, whereas Riley’s aligns with critiques of open borders.

Immigration advocacy groups and legal experts have pushed back against the comparisons. A Facebook post from Immigration Criminal Attorneys stated: “Alex Pretti’s death is not a talking point, and neither is Laken Riley’s. We can hold space for both without pitting them against each other. Comparing one person’s death to another doesn’t make you moral; it only shows you’re trying to rank grief to win an argument.” They emphasized the need for nuanced discussions on use of force, border policies, and public safety without exploiting tragedies.

The debate has also drawn in Second Amendment advocates, with some expressing discontent over perceived inconsistencies in Republican stances. Outlets like WWSB reported backlash from gun rights supporters criticizing the Trump administration’s handling of Pretti’s case, where a legally armed citizen was killed by federal agents. “Important voices in Trump’s coalition have been criticizing inconsistencies in some Republicans’ Second Amendment stances since the killing,” the report noted.

Pretti’s family has rejected characterizations diminishing his legacy, describing him as a “kindhearted soul” dedicated to veterans and upset by aggressive ICE tactics. They cited video evidence contradicting DHS claims and called for transparent investigations. Friends and former classmates from Green Bay, Wisconsin, have shared multifaceted remembrances, portraying Pretti as outgoing, principled, and caring, though acknowledging his activism reflected strong convictions.

Riley’s family, through statements during Ibarra’s ongoing trial, has focused on seeking justice and advocating for reforms like the Laken Riley Act, which aims to detain undocumented immigrants charged with certain crimes. They have expressed frustration with politicization but welcomed attention to border security.

As investigations into Pretti’s shooting continue—with FBI and Homeland Security reviewing bodycam footage and bystander videos—the controversy underscores polarized views on immigration enforcement, media coverage, and public sympathy. Experts note that such comparisons often reflect broader ideological divides: conservatives highlighting crimes by undocumented individuals to critique policies, while liberals focus on alleged overreach by authorities.

In Minneapolis, protests have persisted, with demonstrators blocking streets and holding signs honoring Pretti and Renee Nicole Good, another U.S. citizen killed by federal agents earlier in January. National figures, including late-night hosts like Jimmy Kimmel, have weighed in, calling Pretti’s death “vile and heartless” in monologues that critique enforcement tactics.

The opinion pitting Pretti against Riley has amplified calls for balanced discourse. As one social media user put it: “Both were nurses trying to help people. Both deaths are tragedies. Using one to downplay the other helps no one.” Yet, with emotions running high, the debate shows no signs of abating, reflecting deeper tensions in American society over justice, borders, and who deserves remembrance.