😱 JUST BINGED ‘THE BEAST IN ME’ ON NETFLIX? Your Heart’s Still Racing from That Insane Cat-and-Mouse Game Between Claire Danes and Matthew Rhys… But Now What?! 😱

You thought the twisted neighbor obsession, the buried secrets, and that jaw-dropping finale were peak thriller vibes… but wait until you dive into THESE 6 crime shows that hit EVEN HARDER.

One has a creepy stalker watching your every move… another exposes elite families hiding BLOOD on their hands… and there’s a disappearance that rips a marriage apart in ways you WON’T see coming.

If “The Beast in Me” left you paranoid about your own neighbors and craving more mind-bending psychological drama, these will destroy your sleep schedule.

Which one are you starting TONIGHT? Drop it below and tag a friend who’s obsessed with thrillers – they NEED this list! 👇🔥

Netflix’s latest hit, The Beast in Me, has gripped viewers since its November 13, 2025, premiere, rocketing to the top of the streamer’s charts with its slow-burn psychological showdown between a grieving author and her suspicious neighbor. Starring Claire Danes as reclusive writer Aggie Wiggs and Matthew Rhys as charismatic real estate mogul Nile Jarvis—once the prime suspect in his wife’s disappearance—the eight-episode limited series explores obsession, grief, and moral ambiguity in a wealthy suburban setting. Critics have praised the lead performances, with Rotten Tomatoes noting it “stages a psychological duel that crackles with tension,” while some reviewers called out familiar tropes in the plot.

If you’ve already binged all episodes and are hunting for more shows that capture that same mix of neighborly paranoia, elite secrets, and cat-and-mouse mind games, these six crime thrillers should scratch the itch. From stalker nightmares to family betrayals among the rich, here’s what to stream next.

The Watcher (Netflix, 2022) Ryan Murphy’s creepy limited series, based on a true story, follows a family (Naomi Watts and Bobby Cannavale) who move into their dream home in suburban New Jersey—only to receive threatening letters from an anonymous “Watcher” obsessed with their lives. Like The Beast in Me, it taps into the horror of invasive neighbors and the unraveling of domestic bliss under scrutiny. The show builds unbearable tension through escalating paranoia, with Jennifer Coolidge stealing scenes as a nosy real estate agent. It earned mixed reviews for its wild twists but became a massive hit for its addictive, binge-worthy dread.
The Undoing (HBO/Max, 2020) Nicole Kidman and Hugh Grant star in this glossy miniseries about a successful therapist whose perfect Upper East Side life crumbles when her husband becomes the suspect in a brutal murder. Directed by Susanne Bier and created by David E. Kelley, it mirrors The Beast in Me‘s focus on privileged families hiding dark truths and the psychological toll of suspicion within marriages. Grant’s charming-yet-sinister turn echoes Rhys’ enigmatic Nile, while Kidman’s unraveling performance draws parallels to Danes’ grief-stricken Aggie. The courtroom drama and elite society backdrop kept viewers hooked, though some criticized the ending as predictable.
Big Little Lies (HBO/Max, 2017-2019) This star-studded adaptation of Liane Moriarty’s novel features Reese Witherspoon, Nicole Kidman, Shailene Woodley, Zoë Kravitz, and Laura Dern as Monterey moms whose lives intertwine through secrets, abuse, and a mysterious death. Season 1’s murder mystery unfolds via flashbacks and interrogations, much like the layered revelations in The Beast in Me. The show’s exploration of facades in affluent communities, domestic tension, and female alliances made it a cultural phenomenon, earning Emmys galore. Meryl Streep’s addition in Season 2 amps up the interpersonal drama, though the first season stands strongest.
Disclaimer (Apple TV+, 2024) Directed by Alfonso Cuarón, this psychological thriller stars Cate Blanchett as a acclaimed documentary filmmaker whose life implodes when a novel exposes her hidden past. Kevin Kline and Sacha Baron Cohen co-star in a tale of secrets, revenge, and narrative manipulation. Fans of The Beast in Me‘s writer-protagonist digging into dangerous truths will appreciate the meta layers here, as well as the intense personal confrontations. Critics hailed Blanchett’s performance and Cuarón’s stylish direction, calling it a standout for its intellectual twists and emotional depth.
Fool Me Once (Netflix, 2024) Another Harlan Coben adaptation, this British miniseries follows Maya (Michelle Keegan), a widow who spots her murdered husband on nanny cam footage weeks after his death. Co-starring Joanna Lumley and Richard Armitage, it piles on family secrets, betrayals, and shocking reveals in classic Coben fashion. The fast-paced plot and themes of deception within close circles align closely with The Beast in Me‘s marital suspicions and hidden motives. It topped Netflix charts upon release, praised for its bingeable twists despite some formulaic elements.
The Stranger (Netflix, 2020) Yet another Coben hit, this one centers on a mysterious woman (Hannah John-Kamen) who approaches strangers with devastating secrets about their loved ones, upending Adam Price’s (Richard Armitage) idyllic family life. The ripple effects uncover lies, disappearances, and corruption. Like Danes’ Aggie obsessively probing her neighbor, Armitage’s character dives headfirst into a web of intrigue. The show’s relentless pacing and multiple interconnected mysteries made it a quick fan favorite, with strong ensemble work keeping the suspense high.

These recommendations lean into the psychological crime thriller subgenre that The Beast in Me excels at—stories where ordinary lives fracture under the weight of buried truths, often in upscale settings with unreliable narrators. Streaming habits in 2025 have favored limited series like these, allowing for tight storytelling without filler seasons.

The Beast in Me itself drew from influences like true-crime obsessions and classics such as Rear Window, but its success owes much to the chemistry between Danes and Rhys. Danes, reuniting with Homeland showrunner Howard Gordon, delivers a raw portrayal of grief-fueled fixation, while Rhys balances charm and menace. Supporting players like Brittany Snow as Nile’s wary second wife and Natalie Morales as Aggie’s ex add layers of complexity.

Viewer reactions have been strong, with social media buzzing about the finale’s moral gray areas—does justice prevail, or do darker impulses win? As of late December 2025, the show sits at a solid 79% on Rotten Tomatoes, with audiences slightly higher at 85%. Discussions about a potential second season persist, though it’s billed as limited.

In a crowded streaming landscape, shows like these thrive by blending domestic drama with high-stakes mystery. Whether it’s the voyeurism of The Watcher or the elite intrigue of Big Little Lies, they capture the unease of wondering who’s really watching—and what they’re hiding.

If The Beast in Me hooked you with its intimate scale and stellar acting duels, these six picks offer similar thrills without straying too far. Just be prepared for more late nights and sidelong glances at your own neighbors. All are available on major platforms as of December 31, 2025, ready for your next binge.