A mother’s worst nightmare unfolded on January 19, 2026, when Mary Mich, 20, and her boyfriend Luke Reimer, also 20, were discovered lifeless inside a gray Ford Bronco Sport parked in the lot of St. Agnes Residence Hall at Franciscan University of Steubenville, Ohio—mere feet from the dorm where Mary lived.

The Jefferson County Coroner’s Office later confirmed the cause: accidental carbon monoxide poisoning from a malfunction in the vehicle’s exhaust system. Toxicology reports showed no foul play, no drugs—just a silent, invisible killer that claimed two young lives full of promise.

Christy Mich, Mary’s mother and a dance teacher, opened up about the devastating moment she learned of the tragedy and the painful details that followed. She described the scene that first responders encountered: Luke resting gently on Mary inside the car, as if they had simply fallen asleep together. “They definitely had true love,” Christy said, her voice breaking as she recalled how the couple had been inseparable since meeting at the Catholic university. They had celebrated their one-year anniversary not long before, sharing dreams of marriage and a large family.

The young pair had spoken often of their future wedding, plans that now seem cruelly ironic. In a final act of love, their families chose to bury them wearing wedding bands—symbols of the commitment they never got to fulfill in life. Mary, from Downingtown, Pennsylvania, and Luke, from Indian Shores, Florida, where he played defense on the men’s lacrosse team, were juniors pursuing their passions: Mary in her studies and Luke in business.

The university community was plunged into grief. Franciscan University President Fr. Dave Pivonka addressed the campus, expressing profound sorrow and calling for prayers for the families. “We grieve the loss of two young lives,” he said, noting early signs pointed to a vehicle malfunction. The parking lot spot, so close to safety, only amplified the heartbreak—help was agonizingly near, yet unreachable.

Weeks earlier, reports emerged that the couple had mentioned smelling gas in the vehicle, a warning sign tragically overlooked amid busy college life. This detail has sparked renewed warnings about vehicle maintenance, especially exhaust systems, as carbon monoxide remains a silent threat in enclosed or faulty cars.

For Christy Mich and her family—including Mary’s twin sister Lily and siblings—the pain is unending. They remember Mary as vibrant, faithful, and deeply in love. Luke’s family echoes the same, cherishing his maturity and devotion. Both obituaries highlight how the couple “took their last breaths together,” united even in death.

This tragedy serves as a stark reminder of life’s fragility. In the quiet moments of a winter day, two souls with endless dreams slipped away, leaving behind grieving parents, a mourning campus, and a question that echoes: How many more preventable losses before we heed the warnings? For one mother, the image of her daughter and her love, side by side forever, is both a comfort and an unbearable wound.