In a gut-wrenching update that’s sending shockwaves through Long Island, new details in the November 26, 2025, slaying of 18-year-old Emily Finn paint an even more horrifying picture of obsession turned deadly. Contrary to initial reports, the aspiring ballerina and SUNY Oneonta freshman didn’t arrive at her ex-boyfriend’s Nesconset home alone that fateful morning. Court documents unsealed this week reveal she was accompanied by a close friend for moral support during what was meant to be a quick handoff of belongings after their three-year romance crumbled. Suffolk County prosecutors now say this “protective measure” inadvertently thrust the friend into a nightmare, witnessing Lynch’s calculated rage unfold in real time.

Emily Finn, a radiant Sayville High School graduate and lifelong dancer at the American Ballet Studio in Bayport, had returned home from college for Thanksgiving break. Their split two weeks prior had been acrimonious: Austin Lynch, then 17, bombarded her with calls from burner phones and social media tirades, escalating from possessiveness to outright threats. Friends described Lynch as “overbearing,” accusing Finn of infidelity amid her new campus life. Undeterred, she agreed to meet – but not solo. “Emily was smart; she brought backup because she sensed the volatility,” a family source confided. The friend, whose identity remains shielded, waited in the car outside Lynch’s Shenandoah Boulevard North residence, engine idling for a swift exit.

What happened next? Prosecutors allege Lynch, seething over the breakup, lured Finn inside under the pretense of civility. As she turned to leave – keys in hand, coat still on, purse at her feet – he allegedly loaded exactly two shells into the family shotgun. The first blasted into the back of her head in an “execution-style” shot from point-blank range, prosecutors detailed during Lynch’s December 4 arraignment. Finn collapsed lifeless mere feet from the entryway. In a botched suicide bid, Lynch turned the barrel on himself, surviving with severe facial fractures and a cranial leak. His parents discovered the carnage and dialed 911, rushing him to Stony Brook University Hospital.

But the true horror? A dashcam from a neighbor’s parked vehicle captured the prelude and immediate aftermath in stark clarity. Footage, entered as evidence this week, shows Finn’s car pulling up around 11 a.m., the friend gesturing supportively from the passenger seat. Moments later, muffled screams echo before silence – then Lynch’s parents bolting from the house, bloodied and frantic. “It details every barbaric step: the ambush, the shot, the survivor’s stagger,” Assistant District Attorney Dena Rizopoulos stated in court. The video’s release has ignited fury, with advocates decrying it as a stark reminder of intimate partner violence’s stealthy escalation. No prior domestic reports existed, underscoring how “normal” teen relationships can mask red flags like isolation tactics and digital stalking.

Lynch, now 18 and indicted on second-degree murder, pleaded not guilty on December 4 before Judge Philip Goglas, who remanded him without bail to an adult facility despite his youth at the time. At a December 10 hearing, his attorney requested a psychiatric evaluation for competency, citing potential mental health factors – a move prosecutors slammed as a delay tactic. Facing 25-to-life if convicted, Lynch’s Marine enlistment dreams now lie in ruins. “This wasn’t impulse; it was premeditated cruelty,” DA Raymond Tierney emphasized. “Emily deserved college, not a grave.”

The community reels: Pink ribbons adorn Bayport studios, a Nutcracker performance dedicates to her grace, and a GoFundMe has surged past $75,000 for her family’s solace. Vigils echo her mother’s eulogy: “She was my pure angel, always kind.” Yet amid grief, calls for reform grow – mandatory breakup safety protocols, expanded teen mental health screenings, and tech tools to flag harassment. Finn’s prophetic text to her mom days before – “If anything happens, know I love you” – haunts. Her death isn’t isolated; it’s a siren for vigilance in love’s shadows. As investigations probe the friend’s full account and dashcam’s unfiltered truth, one fact endures: Emily’s light, though extinguished, illuminates the path to prevention. In her memory, we must act – before another holiday turns tragic.