Steubenville, Ohio – In a chilling development that has reignited speculation surrounding the deaths of two Franciscan University students, police have now confirmed that a handwritten note discovered at the scene of the incident was not written by either victim. The revelation comes weeks after Luke Reimer, 20, and Mary Mich, 20, were found lifeless inside a parked vehicle on campus, initially ruled an accidental tragedy caused by carbon monoxide poisoning.

The couple, both juniors at the Catholic university, were discovered shortly after noon on January 19 in a gray Ford Bronco parked in the lot behind St. Agnes Residence Hall, a women’s dormitory. University officials described it early on as a “tragic accident” potentially linked to a vehicle exhaust or engine malfunction. Toxicology reports from the Jefferson County Coroner’s Office later confirmed both died from carbon monoxide exposure, with authorities stressing no signs of foul play, drug use, or violence.

Yet the presence of the handwritten note—left inside or near the vehicle—has fueled online discussions and questions about what really happened that fateful day. Steubenville Police, after forensic analysis, announced that the handwriting does not match that of Luke Reimer or Mary Mich. It belongs to “someone else,” though officials have not released further details about the note’s content, who might have written it, or how it ended up at the scene.

The university community remains in deep mourning. Father Dave Pivonka, president of Franciscan University, issued a heartfelt statement expressing profound sadness over the loss of two beloved students. Reimer, from Indian Shores, Florida, and Mich, from Downingtown, Pennsylvania, were remembered as vibrant young people active in campus life. Friends noted the pair had recently celebrated milestones in their relationship, adding to the heartbreak.

While the official ruling stands as accidental—likely from a faulty exhaust system allowing deadly fumes to seep into the cabin while the engine ran—the mismatched handwriting has sparked theories. Was the note a suicide pact message from a third party? A farewell from a friend? Or something unrelated left behind coincidentally? Police have reiterated that the investigation found no evidence of criminal intent, but the handwriting confirmation ensures the case won’t fade quietly.

Campus safety advocates are now calling for greater awareness about carbon monoxide risks in vehicles, especially in cold weather when people might run engines to stay warm. Franciscan University has offered counseling and support services to students grappling with grief.

As details trickle out, the handwritten note stands as the most puzzling element in what was supposed to be a straightforward accident. For now, authorities urge the public to respect the family’s privacy while the full picture emerges. One thing is clear: this heartbreaking story is far from over.