In a whirlwind of joy, surprise, and unexpected drama, Fox News’ Outnumbered co-host Kayleigh McEnany and her husband, former MLB pitcher Sean Gilmartin, recently welcomed their third child, a beautiful baby girl named Avery Grace. The couple, already parents to daughter Blake, 5, and son Nash, 2, shared their elation with the world, with McEnany posting heartfelt messages on social media, accompanied by a touching biblical passage from Psalm 139 celebrating the miracle of life. However, what began as a heartwarming milestone quickly took a sensational turn when an ex-boyfriend from McEnany’s past sent an astonishing gift to mark the occasion, sparking a reaction from Gilmartin that left family, friends, and colleagues stunned.

A Joyous Arrival

The arrival of Avery Grace was announced on Outnumbered in late June 2025, with co-host Emily Compagno beaming as she shared the news of the newest addition to the McEnany-Gilmartin family. McEnany, 37, a former White House Press Secretary under President Trump, has long been a prominent figure in conservative media, known for her sharp commentary and poised demeanor. Her pregnancy, first revealed on air in March 2025, was a journey she shared openly with viewers, culminating in a gender reveal in May where she, Gilmartin, and their two children celebrated the news of a second daughter. The couple’s joy was palpable, with McEnany expressing gratitude for their growing family and the outpouring of support from fans and colleagues alike.

The birth of Avery Grace was a moment of pure celebration. McEnany took to social media to share her love for her newborn, writing, “Sean and I are so in love with our new baby girl, Avery Grace!” The post included a photo of the couple cradling their daughter, with Blake and Nash curiously peering at their new sibling. Fans flooded the comments with congratulations, praising McEnany’s strength as a mother and her ability to balance a high-profile career with family life. The Outnumbered team, led by Harris Faulkner, sent warm wishes, with Compagno jokingly urging McEnany to “enjoy motherhood and not come back too soon.”

An Unexpected Twist

Amid the flood of well-wishes and baby gifts, one delivery stood out for all the wrong reasons. Sources close to the family revealed that McEnany received an extravagant and deeply personal gift from an ex-boyfriend with whom she had briefly worked earlier in her career. The gift, described as a lavish keepsake with a handwritten note, was intended as a congratulatory gesture for Avery’s birth. However, its intimate nature and the sender’s identity sent shockwaves through the McEnany-Gilmartin household.

The ex-boyfriend, whose identity remains undisclosed, is said to have crossed paths with McEnany during her early days in media, before her rise to national prominence. While their relationship was short-lived, the gift—a custom-engraved item reportedly costing thousands of dollars—suggested a level of familiarity that caught McEnany off guard. The accompanying note, while polite, referenced shared memories from their time together, adding a layer of complexity to what should have been a straightforward gesture of goodwill.

McEnany, known for her composure under pressure, was reportedly taken aback but chose to handle the situation with grace. She acknowledged the gift privately, intending to donate it to a charitable cause to avoid any misinterpretation. However, the real fireworks began when Gilmartin, 35, learned of the delivery.

A Husband’s Protective Fury

Sean Gilmartin, a former New York Mets pitcher known for his calm and supportive demeanor, was anything but composed upon discovering the gift. Described by those close to the couple as fiercely protective of his family, Gilmartin’s reaction was explosive. Sources say he was livid at the audacity of the ex-boyfriend, viewing the gift as an overstep that disrespected his wife and their marriage. His response was so intense that those around him—family members, friends, and even household staff—found themselves treading carefully, wary of his uncharacteristic anger.

Gilmartin, who married McEnany in 2017 after a whirlwind romance sparked by a direct message on X in 2015, has always been a steadfast partner. The couple’s love story, detailed in McEnany’s memoir For Times Such As This: My Faith Journey Through the White House and Beyond, is one of mutual respect and shared values. The intrusion of an ex-boyfriend’s gesture, however well-intentioned, struck a nerve, prompting Gilmartin to take a stand. While the specifics of his reaction remain private, it’s said that he made it clear to those around him that such gestures were unacceptable, leaving no room for ambiguity.

The tension was palpable, with those in the couple’s inner circle describing an atmosphere where “no one dared approach Sean for days.” McEnany, ever the diplomat, worked to diffuse the situation, reassuring her husband of her commitment to their family and redirecting their focus to the joy of Avery’s arrival. Her ability to navigate the drama with poise only reinforced her reputation as a woman who thrives under pressure.

The Bigger Picture

The incident, while deeply personal, highlights the unique challenges faced by public figures like McEnany. As a Fox News star and former White House official, her life is under constant scrutiny, with every milestone—personal or professional—amplified by media attention. The arrival of Avery Grace should have been a moment of unadulterated joy, but the unexpected gift and its fallout underscore the complexities of navigating past relationships in the public eye.

McEnany’s journey to this point has been one of resilience. From her tenure as White House Press Secretary during the tumultuous final year of the Trump administration to her role as a leading conservative voice on Fox News, she has faced criticism, health scares (including a fainting incident on air in 2025), and the demands of motherhood with unwavering determination. Her faith, often cited as a cornerstone of her life, has guided her through challenges, and it’s likely that same faith helped her and Gilmartin move past this unexpected drama.

The couple’s story also resonates with broader themes of love, loyalty, and family. Gilmartin’s protective reaction, while intense, reflects a husband’s instinct to shield his wife and children from perceived slights. McEnany’s response, measured yet firm, showcases her ability to rise above controversy while keeping her family first. Together, they’ve weathered a storm that could have derailed lesser partnerships, emerging stronger and more united.

Looking Ahead

As the dust settles, McEnany and Gilmartin are focusing on what matters most: their three children and their shared future. Avery Grace, blissfully unaware of the drama surrounding her arrival, is the center of their world, with Blake and Nash slowly adjusting to their roles as big sister and brother. McEnany is expected to take a brief maternity leave from Outnumbered, with plans to return to the airwaves later in 2025, bringing her signature wit and insight to viewers.

The ex-boyfriend’s gift, now a footnote in an otherwise joyful chapter, serves as a reminder that even the most carefully curated lives can be upended by unexpected twists. For McEnany and Gilmartin, it was a test of their bond—one they passed with flying colors. As they embrace this new phase of parenthood, their story is one of triumph over adversity, a testament to the strength of their love and the resilience of their family.

Fans of McEnany continue to shower her with support, eagerly awaiting updates on Avery’s milestones and McEnany’s return to Fox News. In a world where headlines often dwell on division and conflict, the McEnany-Gilmartin family offers a refreshing narrative of unity, faith, and the enduring power of love.