In a devastating turn of events that has gripped communities in Florida and beyond, 33-year-old attorney Brandon Billmaier and his 57-year-old uncle, Randall Spivey, disappeared during a routine deep-sea fishing excursion off the coast of Fort Myers on December 19, 2025. The two experienced boaters, both personal injury lawyers passionate about the outdoors, set out early that morning aboard a 42-foot Freeman catamaran named “Unstopp-A-Bull,” expecting to return by sunset. Tragically, they never did.

Brandon, a recent graduate of the University of Toledo Law School who had recently married his wife Deborah, shared a quiet, intimate dinner with her the evening before the trip—a simple Thursday night meal that now haunts her as their final moments together. Deborah later reflected on those precious hours, describing how Brandon lived for his family, his new marriage, and his love of fishing. “Sometimes just those simple moments are the best,” she shared in interviews, finding bittersweet comfort in knowing he spent his last hours pursuing his greatest passion.

The alarm was raised that Friday night when the men failed to return. A massive search operation swiftly launched, involving the U.S. Coast Guard, local agencies, and volunteers from across the Southeast. Early Saturday, a Coast Guard helicopter located the empty vessel adrift approximately 70 miles offshore, still in gear with the engine running. Fishing gear remained onboard, along with freshly caught fish, but there was no sign of Brandon or Randall. Notably, two life jackets were missing, sparking hope that the men might have donned them after an accident.

Authorities believe the incident occurred while the pair were bottom fishing. One likely fell overboard unexpectedly—possibly due to a medical emergency or mishap—and the other jumped in to help, unaware the boat’s engine was engaged. The vessel drifted away, leaving them stranded in the vast Gulf of Mexico. Despite exhaustive efforts covering an area larger than the state of Connecticut, including air and sea patrols, the official search was suspended at sunset on December 22, pending new leads. The case has since transitioned to an FBI missing persons investigation.

Brandon, who worked at the Shiner Law Group in Boca Raton after moving to Florida to follow in his uncle’s footsteps, was described by colleagues as an exceptional lawyer and person. Randall, a prominent Fort Myers attorney, was known for his integrity and dedication to family. The two shared a close bond, often fishing together with extended family.

Deborah, now facing an unimaginable holiday season without her husband, has expressed profound grief while honoring the rescuers’ efforts. “Brandon and Randy would never want anyone else to put their life in danger,” she posted, urging respect for the difficult decision to suspend the search. As families cling to fading hope, this tragedy serves as a stark reminder of the Gulf’s unforgiving dangers, even for seasoned boaters. The community continues to pray for closure in this heartbreaking mystery.