In a stunning twist that has left investigators reeling, the family of Hector Lionel Alfaro—the man authorities say carried out a brutal murder-suicide in Lakewood, California—has formally requested the exhumation of his body. They insist their son could not possibly have committed the horrific act of gunning down his wife, Roxana Rodriguez, 48, and their 17-year-old daughter, Sienna Alfaro, before turning the gun on himself.

The tragedy unfolded on a quiet Thursday morning in the 5800 block of Lorelia Avenue. Deputies responded to reports of shots fired and discovered a scene of unimaginable horror: Roxana in one bedroom with fatal gunshot wounds to her torso, Sienna in another with similar injuries, and Hector in the den, dead from a self-inflicted wound. Two firearms were recovered at the home. A surviving 19-year-old daughter narrowly escaped after her father allegedly fired at her multiple times but missed.

Authorities quickly classified the incident as a murder-suicide, with Hector identified as the perpetrator. The motive remains unclear, though reports suggest tensions in the marriage may have played a role, including possible infidelity discovered months earlier. A candlelight vigil was held days later to honor Roxana and Sienna, while a GoFundMe campaign supports the grieving surviving children.

Now, Hector’s family refuses to accept the official narrative. They claim their son—a devoted husband and father—was incapable of such violence. In a desperate bid to prove his innocence, they are pushing for the exhumation of his remains to allow for independent forensic examination, including toxicology tests and a second autopsy. They argue that external factors, such as undiagnosed mental health issues or foul play, could have contributed to the events.

The family’s demand has sparked intense debate. Supporters see it as a quest for truth in a case that has devastated two families. Critics worry it could reopen painful wounds for Roxana’s loved ones and delay closure. Legal experts note that exhumation requests are rare and require strong evidence, often involving court approval and coordination with the coroner’s office.

As the investigation continues, this bold move has reignited public interest in the case. Questions swirl: Was there more to the story? Could Hector have been manipulated or acting under duress? Or is this simply a grieving family’s denial of a heartbreaking reality?

The surviving daughter has spoken publicly, paying tribute to her mother and sister while grappling with the trauma. Community members continue to rally around the victims, with vigils and fundraisers underscoring the profound loss. Whether the exhumation proceeds remains uncertain, but one thing is clear: this tragedy is far from over, and the quest for answers has only just begun.