In the misty, rural heart of Nova Scotia’s Pictou County, a story that gripped the nation with dread and despair took a seismic turn on November 27, 2025—precisely six months after two innocent siblings vanished into thin air. Lilly Sullivan, 6, and her brother Jack, 4, were last seen on May 1, 2025, frolicking in a New Glasgow Dollarama store with family. The next day, their frantic mother, Malehya Brooks-Murray, and stepfather, Daniel Martell, reported them missing from their Lansdowne Station mobile home. What began as a desperate search for “wandered-off” children morphed into a labyrinth of rumors, family feuds, and forensic frenzy, culminating in the shocking arrest of Darin Geddes, a relative entangled in the web of suspicion.

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), mobilizing over 11 specialized units including the elite Major Crime Unit and Criminal Analysis Service, treated the case like a high-stakes chess match. Initial theories of accidental wandering crumbled under scrutiny. Cadaver dogs scoured the property’s nooks—under trailers, into wells, septic tanks, even via drone sweeps—yielding no remains. Polygraphs cleared Martell, yet whispers of abduction and foul play echoed across social media. Enter Darin Geddes, Brooks-Murray’s cousin through her grandmother, who thrust himself into the spotlight under the pseudonym “Derwood O’Grady” on YouTube’s true-crime circuit. In marathon livestreams on channels like “It’s A Criming Shame,” Geddes peddled explosive theories: the children, he claimed, were bundled into a vehicle by their mother and whisked to a native reserve, safe but hidden. He boasted of “insider knowledge” from unnamed sources and Janie Mackenzie, the children’s step-grandmother, while slamming the RCMP for ignoring his “leads.”

These weren’t idle chats; Geddes’s rants drew hundreds of viewers, fueling a toxic online vortex. Reddit threads on r/JackandLilly dissected his motives, branding him a “conman” preying on grief for clicks. Family tensions boiled over—Belynda Gray, the children’s paternal grandmother, confirmed Geddes’s ties but distanced herself from his wild claims. Martell, enduring online vitriol, spoke of blocked social media and relocated kin. The RCMP, stone-faced amid the chaos, pursued a “coordinated and deliberate” probe, sifting tips from across Canada. By October, court documents revealed witnesses hearing a vehicle rumble the night before the alert, and Geddes’s own interviews with investigators where he dangled vague “locations” like bait.

Then, the breakthrough: encrypted digital footprints, unearthed phone records, and a whistleblower’s tip cracked the facade. On this crisp autumn morning, RCMP tactical teams stormed Geddes’s residence in a predawn raid, cuffing the 42-year-old amid cries of innocence. Charged with obstruction of justice, public mischief, and accessory after the fact in child endangerment, Geddes now stares down a potential 14-year sentence. Investigators allege he fabricated evidence to deflect from Brooks-Murray’s circle, possibly to shield a deeper family secret or exploit the tragedy for notoriety. “This arrest peels back layers of deception that prolonged our agony,” said Sgt. Chris Marshall of the Southwest Nova Major Crime Unit, in a rare statement. “We’re closer, but Lilly and Jack remain our North Star.”

The Sullivan saga underscores the perils of vigilante sleuthing in the digital age. Platforms like YouTube amplified unverified narratives, eroding trust and harassing innocents—Martell faced death threats, Gray sought pro bono legal aid for custody rights. Yet, hope flickers: forensic teams now re-canvas reserves and borders, while AI-enhanced pattern analysis cross-references sightings. Nova Scotia’s child welfare advocates decry the case as a wake-up call for better family intervention protocols.

Six months of posters on lampposts, candlelit vigils in Pictou, and a province holding its breath end not with closure, but a fierce pivot. As Geddes’s court date looms in Halifax, the RCMP vows exhaustive pursuit. For Lilly’s gap-toothed grin and Jack’s boundless energy, justice isn’t just served—it’s hunted relentlessly. In this quantum shift from speculation to shackles, one truth endures: no shadow can eclipse a mother’s unyielding fight.