The desperate search for 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie took a chilling turn this month when investigators zeroed in on an unlikely spot: the septic tank at her Tucson, Arizona residence. Nancy, mother of beloved “Today” show anchor Savannah Guthrie, vanished under suspicious circumstances in late January 2026, sparking a high-profile FBI-led investigation that has captivated the public.

Nancy was last seen on January 31 after family members dropped her off at home following a visit. The next day, her family reported her missing. Authorities quickly determined foul play was involved: blood was discovered on the front porch, confirmed to belong to Nancy, and doorbell camera footage captured a masked, armed individual tampering with the device before approaching the door. The suspect, described as around 5’9″ to 5’10” tall with an average build, carried a distinctive backpack later traced to a specific retail brand. A ransom note surfaced, heightening fears for her safety, especially given Nancy’s fragile health and need for medication.

As tips poured in and the reward climbed to $100,000, law enforcement intensified efforts. On February 8, drone footage and eyewitness accounts showed investigators swarming the property once more. Wearing protective gear, they opened the septic tank access point behind the house and methodically probed its depths with long poles, shining flashlights into the murky interior and collecting samples. Experts suggest such searches often target items that perpetrators might have flushed or discarded, believing they would disappear forever—only to end up trapped in the tank’s contents.

The scene unfolded amid growing anguish for the family. Savannah Guthrie, who has shared emotional video pleas for her mother’s safe return, has remained largely out of the spotlight on air to focus on the crisis alongside siblings. Reports indicate the family has been cooperating fully, offering rewards and public appeals while grappling with the uncertainty of whether Nancy is still alive.

The septic tank examination added to a series of dramatic developments, including searches at nearby residences, DNA evidence from an unknown individual on the property, and increased FBI involvement. No official confirmation has emerged about what, if anything, was recovered from the tank, but the move underscores investigators’ determination to leave no stone unturned—or in this case, no layer unprobed—in locating Nancy and identifying her abductor.

The case has drawn widespread attention, with speculation swirling online and in media circles about motives ranging from random crime to something more personal. As weeks pass since her disappearance, the urgency mounts for answers. The Guthrie family continues to hold out hope, urging anyone with information to come forward. For now, the septic tank search stands as one of the most unsettling chapters in this heartbreaking mystery, a grim reminder of how far authorities will go to uncover the truth.