The disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie from her quiet Tucson-area home has taken a dramatic, family-focused turn. Authorities believe the mother of Today show co-anchor Savannah Guthrie was abducted against her will on the night of January 31, 2026, after evidence at the scene—including signs of forced entry, red splatter on the doorstep, and a missing doorbell camera—raised immediate red flags. Sheriff Chris Nanos of Pima County emphasized that Nancy did not leave voluntarily; she was taken by force, and the investigation treats it as a criminal abduction.

Nancy was last seen that evening after dinner at the home of her daughter Annie Guthrie and Annie’s husband, Tommaso Cioni. Cioni, an Italian-born AP biology teacher, reportedly drove Nancy home around 9:50 p.m. and ensured she got inside safely before leaving. The next morning, when she failed to appear at church, family members checked her home and alerted authorities. No suspects or persons of interest have been officially named, with the sheriff stressing that “everybody’s still a suspect” as a standard investigative approach.

Yet speculation has swirled intensely around the inner circle, particularly after law enforcement searched Annie’s nearby home and towed her vehicle for examination. Forensic teams were spotted extracting data from devices there. Rumors amplified online and in media discussions, with some outlets and commentators dubbing Cioni a potential “prime suspect” due to his being the last known person to see Nancy alive. A neighbor’s explosive comment—”I said from the beginning that he was Annie’s husband”—has fueled theories that the abduction may involve someone intimately familiar with Nancy’s routines, home layout, and vulnerabilities. Nancy relies on medication for cardiac issues, high blood pressure, and a pacemaker, heightening urgency for her safe return.

The family—Savannah, Annie, and brother Camron—has released emotional videos pleading for Nancy’s abductor to provide proof of life and make contact. They expressed willingness to pay any demanded ransom (including references to Bitcoin in alleged notes sent to media) while begging for her return. “We received your message and we understand. We beg you now to return our mother to us,” Savannah said in one clip, flanked by her siblings. Multiple messages purportedly from the kidnapper have surfaced, but some have been linked to unrelated individuals, including a California man arrested for sending hoax demands.

As the search enters its second week, investigators have expanded efforts across states, reviewed new messages, and followed leads from the community. Neighbors describe the Catalina Foothills area as unnerved, with frustration mounting over the lack of answers. The case remains active, with the FBI involved and a focus on those closest to Nancy. While no charges have been filed and authorities caution against reckless speculation, the neighbor’s pointed remark has intensified scrutiny on family ties in what was initially seen as a random crime.

The Guthries continue to hold out hope, urging the public to share any information. Time is critical for Nancy’s health, and the family remains united in their desperate call: Bring her home safely.