The disappearance of prominent Florida attorneys Randall “Randy” Spivey, 57, and his nephew Brandon Billmaier, 33, has gripped the nation with its eerie details, especially the heartbreaking revelation from Brandon’s wife about a foreboding feeling that haunted her the night before their fateful fishing trip.

On the evening before the trip, Brandon’s wife was overcome with an inexplicable sense of dread. She pleaded with her husband to stay home, urging him not to join his uncle Randy for the planned deep-sea fishing excursion off the Fort Myers coast. Initially, Brandon agreed, seemingly swayed by her intense worry. The couple, deeply in love and recently married, shared a close bond, with Brandon often prioritizing family alongside his passion for the ocean.

But everything changed the next morning. At precisely 7:37 AM, Brandon received a phone call that altered his decision. He abruptly chose to go ahead with the trip. His wife, listening nearby, could only catch fragments of the conversation—snippets that struck her as ominous and unsettling. Though she couldn’t make out the full details, the tone and words she overheard filled her with even greater unease, reinforcing her belief that something terrible was looming.

Hours later, on December 19, 2025, Randy and Brandon set out early from Fort Myers aboard Randy’s 42-foot Freeman catamaran, named “Unstopp-A-Bull.” They were experienced boaters, avid fishermen who frequently ventured into the Gulf of Mexico. The plan was a routine day of bottom fishing, with an expected return by sunset. But as evening fell, neither man contacted their families, sparking immediate alarm.

By midnight, the U.S. Coast Guard located the boat adrift approximately 70 miles offshore, near Naples and Marco Island—still running, upright, and anchored safely, but eerily empty. No signs of distress were evident, though two life jackets were missing, offering a slim ray of hope that the men might have been wearing them. An extensive search ensued, covering thousands of square miles with aircraft, boats, and volunteers from across the region—one of the largest operations in Southwest Florida history.

Despite the massive effort, the Coast Guard suspended active searching after several days, turning the case over to the FBI for a missing persons investigation. Families expressed profound gratitude for the rescuers while clinging to hope, describing Randy as a devoted family man and respected personal injury lawyer in Fort Myers, and Brandon as a rising attorney in Boca Raton who idolized his uncle and dreamed of joining his firm.

The wife’s premonition and that enigmatic early-morning call have added layers of intrigue to an already devastating mystery. What was said in those overheard words that convinced Brandon to ignore the warning signs? As days turn to weeks without answers, loved ones are left tormented by “what ifs”—a painful reminder of how fragile life can be, even on a calm sea. The Gulf holds its secrets tightly, leaving two families shattered and a community praying for closure.